|
randombio.com | Science Dies in Unblogginess | Believe All Science | I Am the Science Tuesday, November 17, 2026 | science | opinion Why creationism never seems to gain any traction in scienceCreationists are dogmatic because they see science as dogmatic. Sometimes it is |
ust when we think creationists have finally given up and decided to spend
their days reading Zeitschrift für Geologische Wissenschaften,
they come back a year later with the same arguments
but with an even bigger claim of certainty.
So, what are creationists up to these days? If the article at Townhall criticizing another dreadful documentary on evolution at PBS is any indication, the same thing as always.
The article says that science is closed-mindedly ignoring this amazing new “modern” competitor called intelligent design (ID), i.e. creationism, for which the author says there’s a whole lot of evidence. He cites an article at the Discovery Institute, a creationist think tank, saying it cites hundreds of peer-review articles supporting intelligent design.
Those papers are from places like the Biologic Institute, which is a misleading name for an office rented at one time by the Discovery Institute to make themselves sound scientific. Now it’s little more than a website. Many of the other papers are written by creationists like Behe, Meyer, and Dembski. As with any article, scientific or not, you need to read it critically, re-do any statistics, check the references to make sure they’re real and say what the author claims, and check whether the institution is real or not to avoid being deceived. The Discovery Institute paper fails on all these accounts.
But the Townhall article raises the question: is science as arrogant and dogmatic as the author says?
There are many scientific articles that state their premises, sometimes preposterous ones, as if they’re written in stone. Others publish provably wrong statistics. Some draw invalid conclusions. Some try to stigmatize dissident opinions. Science’s opponents, perhaps thinking this is how science works, take their cue from it and become dogmatic themselves.
Stigmatizing science will never work—scientists are geniuses at ignoring conflicting opinions—but simple stylistic changes would go a long way. It doesn’t take much space to write “there is some evidence that x” or “one theory is that x” instead of stating it as a fact. It raises the status of your paper: If it’s already known, why are you wasting time studying it? It also prevents you from looking foolish when the theory turns out to be wrong, as it inevitably will.
Last week, a famous movie star fell on the ground in LA right in front of a Daily Mail photographer. The coincidence sounded fishy from the start. This newspaper has 406 journalists. If each one has a camera with them at all times, and the population of the UK is 70,116,629, and if we assume this actress rarely falls down, then the probability that this could happen by random chance is less than 1 in 172,702. It’s what actresses have to do nowadays to get back into show biz. This one showed she can do her own stunts and still look glamorous.
It’s a good example of something that might have been done by design (though whether it qualifies as ‘intelligent’ may be debatable) or by a seemingly random event. We also need to consider alternative hypotheses. How do we know, for instance, that the Mail reporter didn’t put a banana peel in her path? Even in everyday life, assigning cause and effect is far from trivial.
I’ve discussed the ‘fine tuning’ argument, the ‘genetic coding complexity’ argument, and the ‘universe had a beginning’ argument that creationists think prove their cause many times. Philosophers have devised even cleverer arguments purporting to prove God exists, but so far none has held up. That doesn’t mean there isn’t one, or that God does or doesn’t exist, but it may be significant that they finally gave up and focused on whether philosophers exist.
Whenever somebody tries over and over to prove that something exists, whether it’s a scientific theory or a religious entity, it means they’ve hit a cognitive dead end. They’re trying to convince themselves it’s true. If you really believed, you’d be more interested in discovering its properties instead of trying to prove it’s real. As Einstein supposedly said when told there was a book with a hundred professors trying to prove him wrong, “If I were wrong, one would be enough” (or words to that effect). If it were possible to prove a deity existed, only one valid proof would be enough. There’s no rush; it’s very hard to prove the existence of something without knowing what it is.
But deception kills a person’s reputation wherever it happens, and its main effect when it’s done by creationists is not to dispel doubt, but to create it.
nov 17 2026, 4:45 am
The universe is not really fine-tuned
How physicists’ attempts to explain the mass of the Higgs boson
almost turned into a proof of the existence of God
Bad statistics in intelligent design
Is Darwin’s theory of evolution really on the verge of being overthrown?
Not by biochemists
Could the universe be eternal after all?
String theory may blow up everything we believed about the Big Bang